Case Study: How a Website Relaunch Quietly Erased a Brand's Search and AI Visibility - Clapping Dog Media

Case Study: How a Website Relaunch Quietly Erased a Brand’s Search and AI Visibility

Client: A direct-to-consumer health and wellness brand Service: SEO + AI Search Audit Approach: Diagnose, then direct

At a glance

  • The problem: Within a year of launching a new website, the brand lost nearly half its organic traffic and more than three quarters of its ranking keywords. Nobody could say why.
  • The diagnosis: The old and new sites ran side by side for months, a Google core update landed in the middle of it, and the brand had too little authority beyond its own website.
  • The AI impact: Appearances in Google’s AI Overviews and People Also Ask boxes fell by more than 75%.
  • The outcome: A clear root cause, a list of fixes the brand’s own team could start right away, and a 90-day plan to rebuild AI visibility.

The situation

For years, the brand’s educational articles had done a lot of quiet work. They answered the questions customers asked before buying, brought steady traffic from Google, and earned spots in AI-generated answers.

Then the brand launched a new website, and over the following months that traffic drained away. The redirects were in place, the homepage looked fine, and the store was still selling. The team knew something was wrong but couldn’t pin down what. Was it the redesign? A Google update? Something technical?

The stakes were real. Paid ads carried most of the brand’s growth, and organic and AI search were meant to be the hedge against relying on them.

What we looked at

We combined a full technical crawl, more than a year of ranking and traffic data, a direct check of redirects and on-page tags, a competitor comparison, and a review of the third-party sites AI assistants rely on when someone asks for a recommendation. Then we tested our hypotheses against what the founder told us about how the launch actually happened.

What broke

The technical foundations were healthy. The site scored well on the crawl, and the old article URLs redirected correctly. So this wasn’t a broken-site problem, which is exactly why it was so hard to spot.

The loss was concentrated almost entirely in the educational content. Homepage traffic held steady while the articles lost around three quarters of their visits. Those articles are precisely what Google’s AI Overviews and People Also Ask boxes draw on, so AI visibility fell with them.

Why it broke

Three causes stacked on top of each other.

1. Two versions of every article, for months. The new site was tested against the old one for an extended period, and Google could see both versions of each key article. It split its trust between them, and when the test ended, the new pages never inherited the old ones’ strength. Some articles that once ranked for hundreds of searches now rank for a few dozen.

2. A Google core update landed mid-transition. It hit health-related content while the site was in flux. The articles were years old, had no credentialed author or expert reviewer, and cited no sources. For health content, that’s a liability.

3. Not enough authority off the site. AI assistants answer “what’s the best…” questions from editorial roundups, review sites and forums. We checked the leading roundups in the category: the brand appeared in none of them, while its closest direct competitor appeared in most. Even the product names didn’t match from one sales channel to the next, which makes it harder for AI to describe the brand consistently.

Quick wins the team could ship in-house

The most useful part of the audit was a list of fixes the brand’s own team could make without an agency:

  • Consolidate duplicate pages, so each topic has one strong page instead of several competing ones
  • Rewrite vague title tags into descriptive, searchable ones
  • Use the words customers actually search for on product pages, not internal product names
  • Request re-indexing of pages that dropped out during a stock shortage
  • Tidy up redirect chains and prune stale old content

Where strategy still mattered

Some of the work needed direction rather than a checklist: mapping every old URL to its best new home, rebuilding key articles with an expert reviewer and cited sources, creating dedicated pages for the problems customers search for most, and building a consistent brand identity so AI assistants describe the brand the same way across its website, marketplaces, Google Business Profile and LinkedIn.

Five warning signs for any brand planning a relaunch

  1. Your homepage is fine but your blog traffic is falling. The pages that carried your authority are often the ones a redesign quietly damages.
  2. You’re running old and new versions of the site at the same time. Make sure Google can only index one.
  3. Your expert content has no expert attached. Add credentials, reviewers, sources and visible update dates.
  4. Your brand is described differently on every channel. AI assistants need one consistent story to repeat.
  5. You’re missing from the roundups. If the “best of” articles don’t mention you, AI assistants probably won’t either.

Is this happening to you?

We diagnose what broke and why, then tell your team exactly what to fix.
➡️ Book an AI Visibility Audit

About Meg Clarke

Meg Clarke is the founder and CEO of Clapping Dog Media, an SEO and AI visibility consultancy she started in 2015. She helps local service businesses, founders and marketing agencies get found, cited and recommended by AI tools, including ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google’s AI Mode and AI Overviews, as well as in traditional Google search.

Site Design Rebecca Pollock
Site Development Alchemy + Aim
Clapping Dog Media Logo
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.